Both the Maple Leaf and American Eagle are among the most widely traded gold bullion coins in the world. You can’t go wrong with either. Subtle differences based on preference and objective criteria may direct you towards one over the other.
The first and arguably most significant difference is purity. The Maple Leaf is .9999 pure gold, while the Eagle is .9167 and is the equivalent of 22kt gold.
On paper this makes the maple leaf appear to be the clear winner but purer isn’t always better depending on your preferences. The Maple Leaf is more prone to wear during handling because nearly solid gold is soft as metals go. This shouldn’t be an issue for most however because there is no reason to be handling bullion coins in the first place. If you wish to admire the design put it in coin capsule.
Although popular worldwide, clearly the American Eagle has a slight edge on U.S. soil when it comes to trading and desirability. The same is true of the Maple Leaf on Canadian soil. Internationally it’s extremely close although the Maple Leaf may be a touch better.
Premiums over spot will also very depending on your location. The difference may seem negligible but in finance every dollar counts, especially if you buy in one part of the world and sell in another.
American Gold Eagle Facts
This coin features the same stunning figure of Liberty as the Saint-Gaudens double eagle. Miley Busiek created the reverse design of a soaring eagle in 1986; the same year the American Gold Eagle was introduced.
Face value: $50 USD
Mass: 33.930 g (1.0909 troy oz)
Diameter: 32.70 mm
Canadian Gold Maple Leaf Facts
The reverse of the Maple Leaf was designed and first released in 1979. Obverse portrait of Queen Elizabeth II is consistent with current Canadian coinage.
Face value: $50.00 CAD
Mass: 31.1035 g (1 troy oz)
Diameter: 30.00 mm
According to the ‘APMEX Top 40’ products, the Maple Leaf ranks right up with there with bullion staples such as the American Eagle, Buffalo, and South African Krugerrand.
Ignoring fractional coins and getting to the heart of which basic types are most commonly bought and sold at APMEX, we’re left with the following list:
- Gold American Eagle
- Gold (American) Buffalo
- Gold Canadian Maple Leaf
- Gold South African Krugerrand
- Gold Austrian Philharmonic
- Australian Gold Kangaroo
- Gold Austrian/Hungarian 100 Corona AGW .9802
- Gold French 20 Franc Rooster AGW .1867
- Gold Swiss 20 Franc AGW .1867
- Gold British Sovereign AGW .2354
So how has the Maple Leaf managed to keep its position near the top, just under the US Mint’s offerings?
Reputation and familiarity no doubt are factors that account for the continued success of the Maple Leaf.
Another popular choice, the Krugerrand, was the first gold bullion coin produced in an exact 1-ounce size (1967), making it ideal for trade. South Africa’s first competitor was the Royal Canadian Mint (RCM) when the Maple Leaf was released in 1979.
Unmatched purity is an additional factor explaining the popularity of the Maple Leaf. Competitors such as the Krugerrand and American Eagle are 91.67% fine.
The RCM raised the bar with the Maple Leaf. Coins minted between 1979 and 1982 have a gold content of .999, and this spec was improved to .99999 fine.
In 1982, Canada set a new standard in the purity of gold bullion. Before 1982 the Maple Leaf was .999 gold; after it was minted with .9999 solid gold.
The Royal Canadian Mint has maintained its tradition of leadership in the gold bullion industry by raising the bar once more, to .99999. Once again, history was made, this time in 2008. To honor this historic occasion, the Gold Maple Leaf was given a special design which includes a crosshatched pattern.
This purity won’t replace the Mint’s standard .9999 Gold Maple Leaf coins in foreseeable future, and is reserved for exclusive special editions produced to show off the Royal Canadian Mint’s unparalleled achievements in coin minting. These coins are highly sought after by collectors and investors because of the purity of the gold as well as the low mintage.
Superior purity makes the Canadian Gold Maple Leaf one of the most sought after gold bullion coins in the world. However, it comes at a cost. The coins are softer and therefore more prone to damage than gold bullion coins such as the American Gold Eagle or Krugerrand. Combined with the milled edge and blank field surrounding the Queen, handling marks show up more easily.